| 5th June 2012, |
Indian
Economy Next Quarter
|
 |
Weak growth numbers calls for rate cut by RBI |
 |
Global commodity inflation, including crude, heading downwards |
 |
Domestic inflation in primary food items to continue, as WPI
inflation stays above the 7% mark |
 |
Rupee to take the brunt of the risk-averse global sentiment and
unfavourable domestic environment |
 |
Savings impacted as household budgets will be hit by lower deposit
rates and higher prices |
|
|
India :
Kal, aaj aur kal |
|
The summer has been harsh so far and there is worse to come. With
every month, the official numbers look worse than before and the official
responses look even more pathetic. One of the biggest farces played out last
month was the petrol price hike, now partially rolled back, all in the name of
deregulated pricing. Yes, crude price hikes necessitated higher petrol prices
since January, but even with the dramatic fall in the rupee, crude oil is
cheaper today than it was in March. The entire episode has left little faith in
this government to act responsibly.
Growth for the January- March quarter was lower than expected, with
the IIP dragging manufacturing down, to levels last seen in 1991-92. While
credibility in the IIP is another issue altogether, the fact is that
manufacturing has been slowing down for a few quarters. This quarter?s numbers
are not likely to shine either - truck rentals for cargo have dipped in April
and May, reflecting a more than 10% decline in despatches from industry.
However, the national manufacturing policy put forth last October is another
old style solution, with the government micro managing industrial zones. In
India, the two fundamental factors of production - land and labour, are mired
in red tape; as we pointed out last year, insulated liberalised zones are not a
sustainable solution and will work just to create more lopsided growth.
Policies that belong to the last century will not work in today?s world, but
this government refuses to step into 2012. The problems have been chalked out
clearly by one and all and are glaring at us in the face now - lower growth and
stubborn inflation, all tied up with a fiscal deficit and current account
deficit that stave off all hope for a revival in the rupee.
It is not just the rate hikes that have brought things to this
pass, but cutting the rates would go a long way in cushioning the shock to
industry. The RBI should go back to its earlier policy when rates had been kept
in check, recognising that the primary drivers for inflation were in the
primary products. Consumer price inflation has been in double digits since
2009, a brief dip for four months has now reversed in April back to 10% levels.
Our real time monitoring of mandi prices has shown that the pressures in
inflation have far from abated. In fact, while so far oilseeds, pulses, fruits
and vegetables have been moving sharply upwards, the steam is coming back now
in cereal prices with inflation in rice and wheat moving back into focus. With
pre-monsoon rainfall deficient across most of the country, a whimsical monsoon
will only add to the pressures in this segment. On the positive side for
manufacturing products, input prices of some core commodities are set to stay
subdued. With the slowdown in China, iron ore prices for instance are expected
to fall 19%. Net net, it would be in order for the RBI to lower rates now;
keeping rates up will not make any difference to inflationary pressures, growth
has to take a priority now.
Over the past year, we were optimistic about the strength of the
economy, but with regressive policies hammering us back a couple of decades,
the outlook has been bleak the last few months. In the spreading gloom, there
are as usual some bright spots. For instance, despite the IIP registering a
negative growth in March for motor vehicles, SIAM production numbers show a
6.83% growth yoy in the same month. April numbers show production up at 5.81%,
with sales rising by 10%. Cement sales have been buoyant, with a 10-12% growth
in May from the country?s two leading cement firms, indicating hope for the
construction sector showing better results this quarter. The HSBC-Markit PMI
for May also shows stability in manufacturing activity, as it has over the past
few months been at variance with the IIP. The services secto PMI showed a jump
in activity in May, the index stood at its highest in three months. While India
Inc?s last quarter results showed a slowing of sales growth, sequential rise in
the operating profit numbers point to a reversal in the 2011 trend.
There is of course nothing like a crisis to get things back on
track. Unfortunately a government in denial, cocooned in a bubble wrap of a
persecution complex, will take longer, if ever, to help India out of its below
7% growth- above 7% inflation mode.
|
|
| Sumita Kale and Laveesh Bhandari |
|
5th June 2012, Indicus Analytics
|
|
Sumita Kale is Chief Economist, and Laveesh Bhandari
is Director, Indicus Analytics. They can be contacted at and
|
| |
Economic
Growth
|
 |
GDP for 2011-12 Q4 turned in a low rate of 5.3% growth
over the previous year, with manufacturing registering a contraction by 0.3%.
Agriculture grew by 1.7%, while mining expanded by 4.3% and electricity by
4.9%. Among services, finance, insurance, real estate and business services
posted a 10% growth, while trade, hotels, transport, storage and communication
grew by 7% and community and personal services by 7.1%. |
 |
HSBC Markit PMI posted 54.8 index value in May,
compared to 54.9 the previous month for manufacturing, while for the services
sector, the index jumped up from 52.8 to 54.7, the highest in three months. |
 |
The eight core industries grew by 2.2% in April,
cement and steel grew the most by 8.6% and 5.8% respectively while natural gas
production contracted by 11.3% and fertilizers fell by 9.3%. |
 |
India?s vehicle production increased by 5.81% in April and sales grew by 8.9%
in May as the petrol hike and proposed diesel tax unnerved the market. |
 |
Electricity production increased by 5.25% in May. |
|
| Read: |
| Read: |
Inflation
|
 |
The WPI provisional inflation for April ticked upwards
to cross 7% again, not just on primary articles inflation but the manufacturing
products inflation increased slightly to 5.12%. |
 |
Steep rise in CPI IW inflation to cross double-digits, 10.22%, while inflation
in CPI AL moved up to 7.84%. |
 |
The new series CPI showed inflation at 10.36% in
April, compared to 9.38% for March, rural inflation was at 9.86% while urban
was at 10.30%. |
 |
International crude oil price has been falling since
March;it averaged $108.13 in May, down from $123.61 in March. Even with the
rupee depreciation, it stands lower in May than in March. |
 |
Petrol price hike that was due since December, came through in May with a Rs. 7.50 rise, that was partially rolled back by Rs. 1.5 in early June. |
 |
Global commodity prices are set to fall, with the Eurozone in trouble and China slowing down. |
 |
FAO Food Price Index fell in May, to its lowest since September 2011. |
|
| Read: |
| Read: |
| |
Interest
Rates
|
 |
The yield on the 10 year benchmark gilt fell over the month of May by 31 bps to touch 8.32% on 4th June. |
 |
Globally rates are moving down - China reduced rates for the first time since 2008 to boost growth now, Australia and Brazil did the same at the end of May. |
 |
The RBI will be pushed to lower rates in its June review, even though inflation from primary food articles still have strong inflationary pressures. The drop in crude and items like iron ore will provide some support for a rate cut here. |
|
| Read: |
| Read: |
| |
Exchange
Rates
|
 |
Exports during April were valued at $ 24455.38 million, 3.23 % higher in $ terms (20.54 % higher in Rs. terms) than last year, while imports were valued at $ 37941.70 million, 3.83 % up in $ terms (21.25 % in Rs. terms) over last year. |
 |
Oil imports during April were valued at $ 13909.2 million, 6.96 % higher than last year, while non-oil imports estimated at $ 24032.5 million were 2.11 % higher than last year. |
 |
The trade deficit for April was estimated at $ 13486.32 million, compared to the deficit of $ 12850.38 million during April 2011. |
 |
The rupee moved lower in May to cross 56 to a dollar. The pressure on emerging markets is felt more deeply in India with its high trade deficit. |
|
| Read: |
Indicus
Price Monitor
|
|
Tracking inflation in real time
The real time monitoring of primary food items at Indicus has consistently shown the pressure on prices in various commodities ? oilseeds, pulses, potatoes and so on ? before they turn around in the WPI. As has been mentioned before, due to differences in methodology, while the levels of inflation and index may differ between the Indicus Price Monitor and the WPI, the broad trends are in sync. The items highlighted in previous months have continued to exert upward pressure on the WPI, and the uptick in manufactured products in April?s WPI showed the impact of rising input inflation.
This month, we look at fibres, a group where inflation had been falling dramatically over the past year as prices came off the peak seen in the first few months of 2011.Cotton in particular had such a steep decline, it beat rubber to be 2011?s worst performing agricultural commodity on global exchanges. Though the supply of cotton is expected to be lower this year, international prices are not expected to rise substantially as demand has also slowed, more than expected. On the domestic front, cotton prices had been coming down, but in March, the government put in a cotton export ban, ostensibly to protect domestic cotton mills. With strong opposition, especially from Gujarat that has the highest production of cotton in the country, the ban was revised within six days. Since then prices have inched upwards marginally, in any case, the decline has stemmed.
Meanwhile, the steep fall in cotton prices has led to lower interest amongst farmers, especially in Gujarat and Maharashtra the two leading cotton producers ? seed sales have dropped by 15% this season. In Punjab and Haryana, that contribute the fourth and fifth largest shares to India?s cotton, the dry and hot weather recently could hurt yields. Clearly, domestic cotton output this year is not expected to be strong, providing a floor to prices. With all these factors into play, the slide in cotton inflation has been reversed, with an uptick in inflation since the end of March.
|
The Indicus Price Monitor currently tracks real time prices for 70 commodities that make up 22% share of the WPI. The coverage of items is being expanded to provide a comprehensive indicator for price information in India.
|
|