|
As expected the Budget was a damp squib, the deficit that had shot
up was brought down a little. The stance of the government is quite clear - all
the talk about intent to reining in fuel subsidies is negated by just one
sentence in the Fiscal Policy Strategy Statement ?With respect to
rationalization of petroleum subsidy, government has already decontrolled the
pricing of petrol.? The fact that the petrol prices have not changed in Delhi
since November, even as the crude basket price rises speaks for itself. To take
another example, for all the talk about encouraging foreign investment, the
turnaround in tax laws has stunned the markets.
To make matters worse, the debate which should have focused on
where our economy was headed was overtaken by drama caused by coalition
politics. Not only are we deprived of any serious talk, credibility is so low
that any positive reassurances for the future are now looked at sceptically.
There has been enough said, both within the government and from analysts about
the structural problems plaguing our economy. As we have said for long now, the
problems and their solutions are well known. Yet, now we have an added issue -
recognition of the structural deficit in the mindset of our policy makers and
in governance - we are therefore stuck in a rut. Gone are the years when we
spoke of achieving a double digit growth path, we are now back to getting the
basics in place - bijli, sadak, paani.
And still there is a lot of hope around that things will take a
turn for the better sometime soon. The MSME Business Confidence Survey
conducted by Indicus Analytics showed an overall brighter picture this quarter
than it did last year at the same time. Official data will reflect better
numbers than Q3the past quarter, the IIP with all its volatility is trending up
now ? while the January number surprised all forecasters by turning in growth
close to 7%, in February too core sector output rose by 6.8%. Keep in mind
though that this does not imply any dramatic upsurge in industrial activity. In
fact, tFor all the twists and turns in the ?statistically bewildering? IIP, we
can still say that there is a high probability that IIP growth will now move up
into double digits by October. The HSBC Markit Manufacturing PMI moved down
marginally in March. butAt the same time t his drop was offset by the fact that
the order book index is still expanding. This is also collaborated with
anecdotal evidence from firms. Any case, going forward the interest rate regime
will favour a more positive environmentthis turnaround, as the RBI will take
small calibrated steps downwards from this month?s policy review.
The reason why the steps in the rate cut cycle will be small and
calibrated is that inflation hasn?t been conquered yet. In fact consumer price
inflation just edged up in February, reversing a decline over the last four
months. Fuel price adjustments remain a ticking bomb and going ahead, as
mentioned earlier, the high fiscal deficit and the low rupee will continue to
feed pressures. Meanwhile under-recoveries register sharp rises ? according to
the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas?s latest figures, the under-recovery
on domestic LPG increased from Rs. 439.5 in March to Rs. 570.5 effective 1st
April.
Interestingly if you want to see a brighter picture for sales, look
into the countryside. Auto manufacturers are making a beeline for the Tier 2/3
cities and tapping into the villages for higher sales. Electronics firms are
also heading out now discovering new territories. Whether it is the effect of
MGNREGA or higher land prices, it is now confirmed that rural consumers are
less dependent on agriculture and have more disposable income. These consumers
do not depend on bank credit and are more comfortable with the cash economy,
and there is a lot of cash going around. With urban Indians reeling under high
food prices, higher rents and transport expenses, higher education expenses,
the rural story may look happier at the moment. The problem is that a system
that runs on transfers is bound to lose steam and unless the economy is put on
a higher productivity path, inflationary pressures will persist. And that is
where we are stuck.
|